Boston
Herald: ARTS & CULTURE
Singers perform vivid `Tosca'
with true passion and bravado
Opera Review/ by T.J. Medrek
Boston Herald, Sunday, March
23, 2003
http://www2.bostonherald.com/entertainment/arts_culture/tosc03232003.htm
Review: Boston
Academy of Music presents Puccini's ``Tosca'' at Northeastern University's
Blackman Auditorium, Friday; repeats today and Tuesday (then
moves to Providence's VMA Arts & Cultural Center for performances on Friday
April 4 & Saturday April 5, 7:30pm.)
There was some roughness around the
edges of Boston Academy of Music's new co-production, with Opera Providence, of
Puccini's ``Tosca,'' which opened a three-performance run at Northeastern
University's Blackman Auditorium on Friday.
But, really, it scarcely mattered. Big-voiced, compelling
performances of the three principal roles by soprano Lori Phillips, tenor Ray
Bauwens and baritone Rene de la Garza - plus remarkably detailed yet unfussy
stage direction by Joseph Bascetta - carried this ``Tosca'' close to greatness.
Set in Rome in 1800, the story is as melodramatic as they
come. Opera star Floria Tosca loves painter-revolutionary Mario Cavaradossi (Bauwens)
but is desired by lustful secret police chief Scarpia (de la Garza). The opera
is basically a series of confrontations between them
that include some of opera's most famous scenes - like Tosca's sensational
murder by steak knife of Scarpia - and are relieved by some of opera's most
beautiful arias, including the soprano's ``Vissi d'arte'' and the tenor's ``E
lucevan le stelle.''
Bascetta filled these confrontations with such life that
audience members could be convinced these were real people in real situations.
The performers looked at and listened to each other intently and reacted to
their increasingly hopeless plights with the naturalness of true, inner
motivation - not pasted-on theatrics. And Bascetta didn't ignore the smaller
roles, eliciting uncommonly vivid portrayals from bass-baritone Drew Poling as
the church Sacristan and tenor Miguel Angelo Rodriguez as Scarpia's chief
flunky, Spoletta.
It took the leads, especially Bauwens and de la Garza, the
first act to fully pull their voices together. But once they did, there was no
stopping them: Bauwens delivered his role with vocal heroism and dramatic
honesty and de la Garza revealed surprising layers of wit, even humor, in a
beautifully rendered portrayal.
Phillips at first appeared too wholesome, too ``American'' to
portray a jealousy-driven Italian diva. But in action she was every inch a woman
stripped layer by layer of her defenses by Scarpia's psychological torture. And
there's plenty enough Italy in her big, robust soprano with its thrillingly
steely high notes.
The sets, designed by Janie Howland and lit by Christopher
Ostrom, were the bare essentials augmented by slide projections that worked best
when they didn't call attention to themselves. Toni Elliott's costumes were
simple and effective. Only the unusually scattershot playing of the orchestra
under conductor Paul Phillips consistently disappointed. |